I have forgotten much of my undergraduate social psychology, but a few bodies of research have stayed with me. One of them found that the harder it is to get into a club, the more you will value your membership. Essentially, the experimenters in these studies varied the onerousness of the things one had to do to become a member of a group---think fraternity hazing. They found that the more severe the initiation ritual, the more value a person would ascribe to the group.
This has to explain the strange phenonemon that is a yarn love group. Let me say before I start that I have nothing against indie yarn dying (actually, I'm in favor of anything creative, and any job that is off the grid, so to speak). For the most part I like the yarn I've bought indie. But man, I don't get the yarn trading scene.
I noticed talk about this yarn on the Rav boards a few months ago, and decided to get some. I found a color I liked, and ordered a skein. It came, it was pretty. So far, so good. Then I decided that I wanted to get another skein to make a large shawl. Given that each color is sold for only a month, no more was available from the dyer. I found someone selling several skeins of my color on the Rav board, and contacted her. At first, the yarns were promised to someone else. Then I got lucky. The deal fell through. Two skeins were available to me, and a little concerned about dye lot matching, I decided to buy them both from this other Raveler, in case they did not match my dye lot, figuring I could always sell mine.
I waited with bated breath. When they arrived, the skeins looked lighter than my one skein, a little bit suspiciously light, but it wasn't until I started knitting with them that I realized this:
Those white spots are just that. White spots where the yarn has no dye. I went back to the boards, and carefully asked about white spots. Understand, the board is visited mostly by grown women waxing rhapsodic about individual skeins of sock yarn, that is, exhibiting the effects of their own severe initiation. Some of these group members (I think of them as beanie baby yarn collectors owing to the fervor with which they buy and trade skeins of yarn) were just sure that those white spots were meant to be there, adding to the beauty of the yarn. Really????
Others were not so starry-eyed, able to admit that sometimes these yarns were shipped out flawed. They did report that the dyer was known to be very accommodating in dealing with problems like this. And I did get one great tip which I'd like to pass on. If this happens to you, you simply need to get yourself a prismacolor marker in the shade of the yarn, and well, just color in those damn spots:
As in the above "after" picture. It works. Annoying, but it does get rid of those white spots. So this project is knit (then tink--it is lace), knit some more, and color. Goofy, and not something I want to have to do again.
Part of the severe initiation in the yarn-trading world is that you buy yarn sight unseen, always a bit of a risk. The potential problem with buying blind just multiplies when you buy second-hand. I don't really want to get into it with the seller. A regular on the boards, did she know that she had been shipped an inferior product but decide to just pass it along? I'll never know. And I really don't have a case with the dyer, since I'm not her customer.
The piece de resistance in terms of hazing is the update. If you're not buying a color of the month, or signing up to blindly purchase yarn in a themed color family (so not appealing for the non-trader), you can purchase at periodic "updates", in which a batch of yarns is posted to the internet for sale at a pre-announced time and then snatched up within moments. First come Paypal shopping carts battling to capture enough skeins of one color to actually make something. People literally talk about yarns being thrown out of their shopping cart, and I can't help picture aisles of self-propelled carts with skeins of yarns flying overhead. Then comes the muted crowing and anguished moaning on the Rav board about what each person managed, or not, to snag in the ten-minute skirmish, followed by feverish negotiations for what was missed.
Not to mention that the yarn sold this way is as expensive or more than anything comparable. All of this "fun" does not come cheap.
Although I'm sure I'll be tempted by the odd skein on-line, for the most part, I try to buy my yarn in person (helps to live in a major city on this one). Touch it, smell it, look carefully at it, and then buy it. Pre-digital yarnies, that's the club I want to belong to. Even though there's nothing onerous about a few hours passed leisurely in a yarn shop. Just think of me as a statistical outlier, the one who messes up the study.